Tuesday, 8 September 2020

07.09.2020 : A monotheist Pharaoh..

 

My first visit to the National Museum (Calcutta) happened at the age of eight. I can't remember anything about that visit, except for the fact that the sight of a ~four-thousand-year old dead body made a rather serious impact. In fact, that sense of fascination mixed with fear has been the characteristic response of the modern world towards ancient Egypt. Innumerable stories have been written on the curse of mummies (even by our own Satyajit Ray), particularly that of the young Pharaoh Tut-ankh-Amun. Incidentally, Tut-Ankh-Amun was a completely insignificant ruler, his current fame arising solely out of the sensational discovery of his unsullied tomb in 1922. However, his father Akhen-Aten (or Amenhotep IV) was a prominent Pharaoh of the 18th dynasty (that ruled Egypt during ~ 1550 and 1070 BCE) and a rather controversial figure (who incidentally may have died from a plague-like epidemic that raged in Egypt and Middle East in the last five years of his seventeen-year long reign).
 
Akhen-Aten (reign ~ 1353 - 1336 BCE) is famous for introducing exclusive Atenism (Aten = Sun) replacing Egypt's traditional polytheistic religion. In his fifth year as Pharaoh, he even changed his name from Amenhotep IV (referring to traditional god Amun) to Akhen-Aten ("Effective for the Aten") and began building a new capital at Akhet-Aten ("Horizon of the Aten") at a previously uninhabited place in between Memphis (near Cairo) and Thebes (Luxor) (which have always been the primary cities of Egypt). Hugely disliked, the cult of Aten was dismantled after his death. His son, Tut-ankh-Amun (born `Tut-ankh-Aten' - living image of the Sun), changed his name (moving the allegiance back to Amun), abandoned Akhet-Aten and returned to Memphis. The 18th dynasty ended with Tut and later Pharaohs (like Seti-I) ordered Akhen-Aten and his familial successors to be excised from the official list of Pharaohs and to be removed from all official records.
 
Atenism is likely the first instance of monotheism in human history. Interestingly, Sigmund Freud argued that Akhen-Aten was the pioneer of a monotheistic religion that later became Judaism. Some even find a precursor idea of Jesus in Akhen-Aten describing himself as born of the Sun-god. Even though such ideas may not have much factual basis, why Akhen-Aten took his Sun-worship to extremes is indeed an open question for historians.
 
To be honest, solar worship had been growing in popularity even before Akhen-Aten, since the Pharaohs of the 18th dynasty were already being depicted in association with the Sun disc. However, Akhen-Aten's obsession with Aten was atypical.
 
Curiously, he proclaimed that "All the gods have stopped (living), except the God who gave birth to himself". Moreover, among the many temples he constructed (for Aten) an important one was named Gem-pa-Aten meaning '(re)-discovery of Aten'. Such clues have led some historians to suggest that Akhen-Aten may have been seriously influenced by witnessing one or more eclipses of the Sun which was interpreted as the death and resurrection of the God.
 
This is not entirely without basis. At Akhet-Aten, there is a unique depiction of the Sun-disk, in the tomb of high-priest Meryre-I. Between the Aten disk and its rays there are several groups of multi-colored arcs. These have been interpreted by some historians as shadow bands visible during a solar eclipse. The collar-like shape of the arcs could perhaps be a depiction of the ‘diamond ring’ effect during totality. Some even think the arcs as some kind of 'time-lapse' portrayal of a total solar eclipse.
 
Now, it is not very difficult to compute the paths of recent and near future eclipses. However, the Earth’s rotation is gradually slowing down and various uncertainties inherent in the deceleration rate can introduce major errors when trying to do a similar calculation for eclipses that are thousands of years in the past. [In fact, it works the other way around. Ancient observations of total solar eclipses are used to measure the rate of change in Earth's rotation.] A curious fact about ancient Egypt is that there are absolutely no mention of any eclipse in the documents. Whether all such records have been lost due to random chance or whether they intentionally kept such events out of the official records is not clear but official Egyptian records are of no help in this matter.
 
Nevertheless, consider the following eclipses that our present calculations put in Egypt between 1399 and 1300 BCE. The ones that are attested by NASA have been marked as such. The other eclipses have been calculated by science historians who have used different parameter values (than NASA) for their calculations.
 
1399 Mar 01 - Hybrid - Egypt
1389 Feb 09 - Annular - Egypt
1378 Jul 05 - Total - Egypt
1375 May 03 - Total - Ugarit, (NASA + historical record)
1360 Jul 15 - Annular - 48N & 4E, (NASA)
1352 Aug 15 - Total - 27N & 10E, (NASA)
1338 May 14 - Total - 23N & 8E , Akhet-Aten? (NASA)
1335 Mar 13 - Annular - Egypt-Canaan
1332 Dec 30 - Total - Nubia
1328 Oct 17 - Annular - 31N & 26E, Egypt (NASA)
 
H - hybrid (combination of annular & total)]
Precise latitude, longitude for the central path not known for any of the above. For comparison, the precise locations of the three places of primary importance in Akhenaten's times are -
Memphis (Cairo) : 30.0444° N, 31.2357° E
Akhet-Aten (Amarna) : 27.6687° N, 30.9020° E
Thebes (Luxor) : 25.6872° N, 32.6396° E
 
According to NASA calculations, the only total solar eclipse visible from Egypt proper during the 14th Century BC occurred on 14 May, 1338 BC and Akhet-Aten fell in the line of totality. If Akhen-Aten became king in 1353 BC (after witnessing the eclipse of 1352 BCE and beginning the Aten-cult thereafter) then 1338 BC would be his 15 th year, so the city would have been built at the time of the eclipse, which could have been the one portrayed in Meryre’s tomb.
Akhet-Aten worshipping Aten
Akhen-Aten worshipping Aten
 
However, a young researcher, Emil Khalisi, has recently suggested (https://arxiv.org/abs/2004.12952) that Akhen-Aten may have ascended the throne in 1382 BCE after witnessing two spectacular annular eclipses in 1399 & 1389 BCE as a child which deeply influenced him. And the total eclipse of 1378 is the one that has been depicted in Meryre's tomb. None of these three eclipses (1399, 1389, 1378) are in the NASA catalog but arise out of Khalisi's calculations.
 
I have no idea about the veracity of these calculations or the exact time-line of Akhen-Aten's reign. But given that many religious practices have astronomical events at their core, I would not be surprised if Akhen-Aten's religious beliefs indeed arose out of his eclipse experience.
 
We will never know what Akhen-Aten did see. We also do not know what people though about eclipses long before any scientific explanation emerged. However, if young Akhen-Aten did happen to be in the path of a total or annular eclipse, the most awe-inspiring natural sight known to humankind, it definitely would have made a deep impact, deep enough for him to abandon all other gods except the bright solar disc in the sky which was, for him, the living god Aten.

Arcs below the Sun-disc, Meryre's tomb.       

       







                                                                                             

No comments:

Post a Comment

08.11.2021 : The Economic Connections..

I hated history in school. So did most of my contemporaries. So do most of today's children. (Can't envisage any change there unless...